Auction Today is the most-reviewed auction app on Shopify, and a good one. Stores usually start looking elsewhere when running auctions gets complicated: features spread across four plans, emails that only start two plans up, and drops that need another app. Rarity takes that complexity away. Auctions, offers and limited drops live in one app, every email is on one plan, and bidder checks are built in from day one. Rarity is our app, so weigh this page with that in mind. Every Auction Today detail below comes from its App Store listing on 13 November 2026; check it before you decide.
Rarity vs Auction Today
✓ marks the stronger option in each row.
| App Store rating | 5.0, every review five stars (6) | 4.9 (334 reviews), Built for Shopify |
| Launched | October 2026 | August 2022 |
| Auctions, offers and drops | All three in one app | Auctions and offers; no drops on the listing |
| Bidder emails (outbid, winner) | Every email on Starter | On Pro and up |
| Bidder checks | Email code, risk score, rate limits and blocking on every plan | Block by email; approved bidders and buyer deposits on Enterprise |
| Plans | 3: Free, Starter, Pro | 4: Free, Starter, Pro, Enterprise |
| Free plan | 3 active auctions | 1 auction |
| Unlimited auctions | Pro, $20/mo ($17 yearly) | Pro, $35/mo |
| Proxy bidding | Yes, every plan | Yes (automatic bids), every plan |
| Late-bid extension | Yes, 2 minutes by default | Yes (popcorn bidding) |
| Reserve and Buy now | Yes, every plan | Yes, every plan |
| Penny auctions | Yes | Yes |
| Buyer's premium | No | Yes, from Pro |
| Make an Offer | Yes, unlimited on every plan | Yes |
| Integrations | Klaviyo and webhooks (Zapier, Make, Mailchimp), on Starter | Klaviyo, Mailchimp, HubSpot, Mailgun, SendGrid, Shopify Flow, on Pro |
| Bulk import, API | No | CSV import and API on Enterprise |
| Storefront languages | English, French, German, Spanish | 9 languages |
| Payment | Shopify draft order, winner gets a checkout link | Shopify checkout, one invoice for several wins |
| Free trial | 7 days | 7 days |
How the plans work
On Rarity, the only question is how many auctions you run. Every email, Klaviyo, webhooks and analytics are on Starter, and Pro removes the limits. On Auction Today, the plan you need depends on which features you want: emails and integrations arrive on Pro, and approved bidders and deposits on Enterprise.
| What you need | ||
|---|---|---|
| A few auctions | Free (3 at a time) | Starter, $9 (Free has 1) |
| Auctions with every bidder email | Starter, $5 | Pro, $35 |
| Unlimited auctions with every email | Pro, $20 ($17 yearly) | Pro, $35 |
| Buyer deposits or approved bidders | Not available | Enterprise, $60 |
Where Rarity fits better
- You want one app, not a stack of them. Auctions, a Make an Offer button and limited drops with countdowns and edition tags share one admin, one set of collectors and one look on your store. A drop can hand its unsold items to an auction when it closes, and an auction can open a drop when it ends.
- You want every email working from the start. Bid confirmations, outbid alerts, winner and payment reminders and second-chance offers to the runner-up all come on Starter, so there's no plan to climb before bidders hear from you.
- You want bidders you can trust. A bidder confirms their email with a 6-digit code before their first bid, and every bidder gets a risk score from verification, bid patterns and rate limits. You can block anyone from the Collectors page. All of it is on every plan, including Free.
- You want checkout to stay on Shopify. A win becomes a Shopify draft order, the winner pays through your normal checkout, and the sale shows up in your reports like any other.
- You want it to look like your store. Four widget styles, restyled from the theme editor, so auctions sit naturally on your product pages.
Where Auction Today fits better
- You want a long track record. Over 330 reviews since 2022 and a Built for Shopify badge. Rarity launched in October 2026.
- You charge a buyer's premium. Rarity doesn't support one.
- You need deposits, approved bidders, CSV import or an API. These are on Auction Today's Enterprise plan. Rarity has none of them yet.
- You sell in more languages, or use HubSpot, Mailgun, SendGrid or Shopify Flow. Auction Today lists 9 languages and more native integrations.
- Winners often win several lots. Auction Today combines them into one invoice. Rarity sends a checkout link per win.
Switching over
There's no import from Auction Today, and you don't need one. Both apps can sit on your store at the same time.
- Install Rarity and turn its auction widget on in a duplicate of your theme.
- Create your next auction in Rarity and run it end to end, with a friend bidding, so you see the outbid email and the winner's checkout link.
- Let auctions already running in Auction Today finish there.
- Publish the theme with Rarity's widget, then uninstall Auction Today once its last auction is paid.
Questions
What do I get on Rarity Starter?
Every email Rarity sends, Klaviyo and webhook integrations, analytics and 25 active auctions. Pro adds unlimited auctions and drops and store-wide auction events. If you need Auction Today's Enterprise features, such as deposits or an API, Rarity doesn't have them yet.
Can I move my auctions from Auction Today to Rarity?
Not automatically. Let running auctions finish in Auction Today and start new ones in Rarity.
Does Rarity charge a fee on winning bids?
No. There are no bid, listing or sales fees on any plan. Shopify's payment processing fees still apply to the order, as for any sale.
Something here out of date?
Both apps change. If you spot a difference from the current listings, tell us and we'll fix the page.
