Shopify has no auctions of its own, so the choice comes down to apps. We make one of them, Rarity, and we have tried to be straight about where the others are stronger. Everything below comes from each app's Shopify App Store listing as of 26 October 2026. Prices and limits change, so check the listing before you install.
The comparison at a glance
| App | Rating | Free plan | Paid from | Unlimited auctions | Emails from |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rarity | 5.0 (6 reviews) | 3 active auctions | $5/mo | $20/mo | $5/mo |
| Auction Today | 4.9 (334) | 1 auction | $9/mo | $35/mo | $35/mo |
| Webkul Product Auction | 4.7 (169) | 1 live auction | $15/mo | $15/mo | Listed, plan not stated |
| Tipo Product Auction | 4.6 (109) | 1 auction order | $8.90/mo | $14.90/mo | $14.90/mo |
| Bidly | No reviews yet | 1 auction | $9.99/mo | $49.99/mo | Listed, plan not stated |
And the bidding features that matter most, as each listing describes them:
| App | Proxy bidding | Late-bid extension | Reserve | Buy now | Fraud tools |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rarity | Yes | Yes, 2 min default | Yes | Yes | Email verification, rate limits, risk scores, blocking |
| Auction Today | Yes | Yes (popcorn) | Yes | Yes (buyout) | Buyer deposits, block by email, approved bidders on Enterprise |
| Webkul | Yes | Yes (popcorn) | Not on listing | Not on listing | Joining fee, ban bidders |
| Tipo | Yes (automatic bidding) | Yes (auto-extend) | Yes (minimum selling price) | Yes | Charge per bid, checkout protection |
| Bidly | Not on listing | Yes (popcorn, Pro and up) | Yes | Yes | Not on listing |
How we compared them
Our guide to Shopify auction apps lists the questions worth asking before you install one. The same questions shaped this comparison:
- Does checkout stay on Shopify? If the app takes payment itself, you lose Shopify's tax, fraud and payout handling and the sale doesn't appear in your reports.
- Is there proxy bidding? Collectors should be able to enter a maximum and let the app bid for them.
- Does a late bid extend the clock? Called anti-sniping or popcorn bidding. Without it, a bid in the last second ends the auction before anyone can respond.
- Reserve and Buy now. A reserve protects your floor. Buy now gives an eager collector a way to end it.
- What stops bad bidders? Verification, deposits, rate limits, blocking.
- Which plan includes emails? Outbid alerts and winner emails do the selling. On some apps they cost extra.
- What does it cost at the size you'll run? Free plans vary from one auction to three. The jump to unlimited runs from $15 to $50 a month.
Rarity
Best for: galleries, print studios and collectibles stores that want auctions, offers and limited drops in one app, without the setup: every email on one plan and bidder checks built in.
Rarity is ours, so read this section with that in mind. It launched on 14 October 2026, and every one of its 6 reviews so far is five stars. What it can't match yet is time: the apps below have years of merchant feedback behind them.
The idea behind Rarity is to take the complexity out of selling rare items. What it does: proxy bidding, late-bid extensions of 2 minutes by default up to a limit you set, reserve and Buy now prices, penny auctions, and durations of 1 to 10 days or your own start and end. A win becomes a Shopify draft order and the winner gets a checkout link with 48 hours to pay, then a second-chance offer can go to the runner-up. Bidders verify an email address before their first bid, and every bidder gets a risk score from verification, bid patterns and rate limits, with blocking from the Collectors page.
The plans are kept simple: three of them, no add-ons, and no fees on any sale. Free runs 3 active auctions at a time with reserve, Buy now and penny auctions included. Starter is $5 a month for 25 active auctions and every email: bid confirmations, outbid alerts, winner and payment reminders, second-chance offers, plus Klaviyo and webhook integrations. Pro is $20 a month for unlimited auctions and store-wide events. Yearly billing brings Starter to $4 and Pro to $17 a month, and paid plans start with a 7-day trial.
Rarity also includes a Make an Offer button and limited edition drops at no extra cost, and the widget comes in four themes you can restyle from the theme editor. See the Shopify auctions page for the full feature list.
Auction Today
Best for: stores that want the most-reviewed option, or need deposits, approved bidders or an API.
Auction Today by Apex Apps has been around since August 2022 and carries a 4.9 rating from 329 reviews and a Built for Shopify badge. That track record is the strongest argument for it. The feature list is broad: proxy bidding, reserve and buyout prices, popcorn bidding, penny auctions, buyer's premium, a Make an Offer option, buyer deposits and blocking by email. It works with Shopify Checkout and integrates with Klaviyo, Mailchimp, HubSpot, Mailgun and SendGrid.
Its features are spread across four plans. Free runs 1 auction. Starter is $9 a month for 15 auctions with bulk creation. Email notifications arrive on Pro at $35 a month, which also unlocks unlimited auctions. Enterprise at $60 adds custom email templates, approved bidders, CSV import, an API and buyer deposits. If outbid alerts matter to you, you'll need Pro. For a closer look, see Rarity vs Auction Today.
Webkul Product Auction
Best for: larger operations that need an API, SMS or WhatsApp alerts, and hundreds of auctions live at once.
Webkul's app is the oldest here, launched in May 2016, with a 4.7 rating from 169 reviews. It supports proxy and popcorn bidding, penny auctions, a joining fee to deter fraudulent bidders, bidder banning, multi-currency and multi-language stores, and notifications by email, SMS and WhatsApp. The listing describes a "seamless winner checkout" without detail, and it does not mention reserve prices, Buy now or an anti-snipe setting by those names, so ask before you rely on them.
Free runs 1 live auction at a time. Starter at $15 a month gives unlimited auctions, a joining fee, automatic winner declaration and several widget themes. Growth at $30 and Pro at $40 raise the live-at-once limit to 500 and add auto-charging the winner, with Pro adding an auction API.
Tipo Product Auction
Best for: small stores on a tight budget that want unlimited auctions and email for under $15 a month.
Tipo launched in June 2019 and has a 4.6 rating from 109 reviews. Every plan includes automatic bidding, a Buy now price, a minimum selling price that works as a reserve, auto-extension of the end time, an optional charge per bid, and checkout protection that stops shoppers buying an auctioned product directly.
Plans count auction orders rather than live auctions. Free covers 1 auction order. Silver is $8.90 a month for 15 orders, with winner reassignment and auction summaries on collection pages. Gold at $14.90 brings unlimited orders, email notifications and a custom SMTP server. Diamond at $24.90 adds multiple admin emails, custom email templates and priority support. Yearly plans are about two months cheaper.
Bidly
Best for: stores that want a customizable auction marketplace page and a live chat beside each auction.
Bidly by Human Intelligence Studio launched in February 2026 and, like Rarity, is new; it has no reviews yet. The listing covers real-time bidding with a popcorn anti-snipe extension, an embedded widget with live bids and a timer, a customizable auction marketplace page, reserve and buy-now prices, customizable email templates and automatic winner order creation. Proxy bidding is not mentioned.
Free runs 1 auction. Basic is $9.99 a month for 3 auctions, Pro $19.99 for 20 auctions with popcorn bidding, widget customization and no Bidly branding, and Enterprise $49.99 for unlimited auctions and a live chat box for bidders. Paid plans have a 7-day trial.
Which one to pick
- You want one app that handles it all, without the setup: Rarity. Auctions, offers and limited drops in one place, every email on Starter, bidder checks on every plan, and a free plan that runs 3 real auctions.
- You want the longest track record: Auction Today, on Pro if you need emails.
- You run hundreds of auctions or need an API: Webkul, on Growth or Pro.
- You want unlimited auction orders with email on a tight budget: Tipo Gold at $14.90.
- You want a marketplace page with live chat: Bidly Enterprise.
Whichever you choose, install it on a development store or a duplicate theme first, run one auction end to end with a friend bidding, and check where the winner's payment lands. That one test answers most of the questions above.
Questions
Does Shopify have a built-in auction feature?
No. Shopify sells at fixed prices. Every option here is a third-party app from the Shopify App Store that adds bidding to your product pages.
Are there transaction fees on auctions?
None of the five charge a percentage of the winning bid. Shopify's own payment processing fees still apply to the order, as they do for any sale.
Can bidders pay without a customer account?
In Rarity a bidder only needs a verified email address and pays through a Shopify checkout link. Other apps vary; Auction Today lists customer accounts among the Shopify features it works with.
How current is this comparison?
Everything was taken from the App Store listings on 26 October 2026, with Rarity's and Auction Today's ratings checked again on 13 November 2026. If you spot a change, tell us and we'll update the page.
