Magical Make an Offer has been on Shopify since 2015 and is one of the best-known offer apps. Its pricing moves with your sales: 1% of paid orders on the free plan, a smaller fee on the $9 plan, and no fee only at $199 a month, with each plan recommended for a different sales band. Rarity takes that complexity away. Each plan has one flat price, no sale ever carries a fee, buyers are checked before they can make an offer, and auctions and limited drops come in the same app. Rarity is our app, so weigh this page with that in mind. Every Magical detail below comes from its App Store listing on 13 November 2026; check it before you decide.
Rarity vs Magical Make an Offer
✓ marks the stronger option in each row.
| App Store rating | 5.0, every review five stars (6) | 4.7 (170 reviews), Built for Shopify |
| Launched | October 2026 | November 2015 |
| How you pay | One flat monthly price, no fees | A per-order fee, or a flat $199/mo |
| Free plan | Unlimited offer listings, no fee | Unlimited offers, 1% on paid orders |
| Paid plans | Starter $5/mo and Pro $20/mo, no fees ($4 and $17 yearly) | $9/mo plus 0.33% on paid orders; $199/mo or $999/yr with no fee |
| Emails to buyers | Every email on Starter | On every plan |
| Where offers appear | Products, whole collections, or store-wide on Pro | Products, cart and order |
| Pay what you want | No | Yes |
| Auto-accept and auto-decline | Yes, as a % of list price per listing (95% and 70% by default) | Yes |
| Counter offers | Yes, by hand, with a payment link | Yes, by hand or by rule |
| Offers per buyer per item | Limit you set, 3 by default | Not on the listing |
| Buyer checks | 6-digit email code, risk score, blocking | Not on the listing |
| Display | Button with a pop-up or inline form, 4 styles | Buttons, banners, inline forms, exit pop-ups |
| Auctions and limited drops | Yes, in the same app | No |
| Free trial | 7 days | 14 days |
A price that doesn't move
A percentage fee means your bill changes every month and grows with your best months, and at some point you have to work out whether to switch plans. Rarity's price stays the same however much sells through offers. Here is the monthly cost on each app at four levels of offer sales, using Magical's lowest-cost plan at each level and assuming its fee applies to orders that came through an offer. The listing says "paid orders" without saying which, so check with them.
| Offer sales per month | ||
|---|---|---|
| $1,000 | $5 | $10 (Starter, 1%) |
| $5,000 | $5 | $25.50 (Growth, $9 + 0.33%) |
| $20,000 | $5 | $75 (Growth, $9 + 0.33%) |
| $100,000 | $5 | $199 (Power, flat) |
Rarity Starter includes buyer emails. Rarity's Free plan costs nothing at any volume but sends no emails, which Magical's free plan does. Shopify's own payment fees apply on both.
Where Rarity fits better
- You want a bill you can predict. One flat price per plan, no fee on any sale, and no sales bands to keep an eye on as your offers start working.
- You sell one-of-a-kind or high-ticket items. When a $4,000 painting sells through an offer, you keep the full $4,000. On a 1% fee, $40 of it goes to the app.
- You want serious offers, not low-balls. Buyers confirm their email with a 6-digit code before their first offer, each buyer can make a limited number of offers per item, and every buyer carries a risk score you can see next to the offer. Auto-accept and auto-decline rules answer most offers for you.
- You'd also run auctions or drops. Turn on "Accept offers" on an auction so a collector who won't wait for the end can make an offer, and run limited drops with countdowns from the same app, with one set of collectors and one look on your store.
- You want checkout to stay on Shopify. An accepted offer becomes a Shopify draft order at the agreed price, and the buyer pays through your normal checkout.
Where Magical fits better
- You want offers on the cart or whole order, or pay what you want. Rarity only does offers on products.
- You want offer banners and exit pop-ups. Rarity shows a button and form on the product page and nothing else.
- You want buyer emails on a free plan. Magical's free plan sends them, in exchange for 1% of paid orders. Rarity's emails start on Starter.
- You want a long track record. 170 reviews over ten years and a Built for Shopify badge. Rarity launched in October 2026.
Switching over
- Install Rarity and add the Make an Offer block to your product template in a duplicate theme.
- Enable Rarity offers on one collection, with your auto-accept and auto-decline percentages set, and turn Magical's button off for those products so each product shows one button.
- Make a test offer yourself, counter it, and pay the draft order from the email.
- Move the rest of your products over, and let any open Magical offers expire before you uninstall it.
Questions
Does Rarity take a percentage of accepted offers?
No. Each Rarity plan has one flat monthly price, and no order or offer carries a fee on any plan, including Free.
Can buyers make an offer on their whole cart with Rarity?
No. Offers are made on a product. You can enable them on single products, whole collections, or the whole store on Pro.
How does the buyer pay once I accept?
Rarity creates a Shopify draft order at the agreed price and emails the buyer an invoice link. They pay through your normal checkout. Our Make an Offer guide covers the whole flow.
Something here out of date?
Both apps change. If you spot a difference from the current listings, tell us and we'll fix the page.
